「「香港名家樂友社」… 啥？」的迴響

作者：123

123 — Sun, 08 Jun 2008 14:43:26 +0000

i dun think that finishing dip ABRSM is worth to be BLOCKED and HIGHLIGHTED lor…. i’m eleven and i’ve finished the LRSM. DIPLOMA isnt everthing. dun u think that those performing that night hv finished their diploma?? they hv their degrees, hv their masters in juliard wteva. can a normal person who hv proudly finished the DIPLOMA criticize the masters?? hv u ever been criticized on ur skills by a 5 grader,dr diploma? i think my words may hurt u but after reading ur ‘opinions’ about the concert, especially on MY teacher(i wont tell u who) i feel very disappointed in the foolishness of musicians in hk and i think i shud say sth about this. this cant be seen by any professionals in other countries, or else I’d never tell people i live in hk again!
123

作者：jever

jever — Thu, 18 Jan 2007 21:42:56 +0000

The name list of the Virtuoso or Virtuosi

Virtuoso is a person highly skilled in the technique of a fine art, esp. music

Virtuosi or Virtuoso pl.

作者：思考／HK-X-Force

思考／HK-X-Force — Wed, 20 Dec 2006 17:53:07 +0000

回 Vm：
歡迎光臨
來年有不少猛人來港，值得一聽：2007上半年頂級音樂會推介。

作者：Vm

Vm — Wed, 20 Dec 2006 12:19:46 +0000

我都有聽e個concert, 如果唔係你講左de錯處出黎, 我都發覺唔到= =

作者：思考／HK-X-Force

思考／HK-X-Force — Thu, 23 Nov 2006 18:49:39 +0000

拉 Paganini Caprice 走音與拉 Bach Concerto 走音是兩回事；兩者走音的程度又是兩回事；教授與 Perlman的年齡亦是兩回事。事件有相似，但程度有不同。

關於 Vivaldi four violin，我是認為是技巧問題高於琴的問題，而且提出我認為是運弓問題的理據，只是你不同意而已，請不要認為意見不同就等於錯誤。我說的是現在沒有人能夠拿出 100% 肯定的證據證明問題在那一方面。

作為是次音樂會的一個觀眾、一個消費者，我認為我所得到的與我所付出的不符，並以較客觀的角度寫出我的見解，當中我並沒有發覺甚麼問題。我的文筆不客套、不轉彎，但這個我的寫作風格。反而，我認為不斷將問題訴諸感情、訴諸人身，就不甚妥當。

至於別人為何能夠登台，這不是我想寫的內容，亦與是次演奏的質素無關，故無意深究。

作者：路人

路人 — Thu, 23 Nov 2006 18:02:21 +0000

Bow arm = right hand. In english, we say bow arm, we don’t mean we play the violin by using the arm only. This is a universal musical language.
In that case, what do you think of the fundamental tech. of the old masters? Ricci has the most brilliant tech and fundamental, but if you listen to his middle age recording, he could not even play the paganini no. 13 caprice in tune. Do you think they didn’t have fundamental? Do you know why Perlman shifted to conducting rather than keep playing the violin? i have listened to his live recently, his playing was still good, but he just simply couldn’t do as well as he could do in his young age. He also played out of tune. Who doesn’t?
If in that case, I think we should cut out the whole orchestra, since the harpsichord is too soft in that hall even playing on his own.
I would say, if the guy really play not well, I don’t think he will be worse than those people who doesn’t have ears. If you can’t tell what is the problem, please don’t critize people harshly!
For a critic, of course you have to have the right knowledge about the subject. If you can’t tell it is the instrument problem or the player own problem, I don’t see you should have this attitude to critize people.
The reason why I say in this way, I don’t mean to hurt people, but I am trying to make you understand how you feel when people say something harsh to you. I know people have his or her own point of view. You can choose like it or dislike it. But there are several ways of saying it. Do you think a negative thinking does you anything good? If you only can pick on people’s negative things, you will never be a good learner. There is always a reason why they are on the stage and people arraging concerts for them, offering jobs for them, but not us. If we do not know the reason, we can only say we are not good enough, and have to learn from those people.

PS: you are right, they made a serious mistake. This is a mock. Shame on it.

作者：一個考左Diploma 既人

一個考左Diploma 既人 — Wed, 22 Nov 2006 14:57:13 +0000

Did you notice he got a fantastic bow arm? I bet you are still in a student level and could not notice it. Nevermind. —–> 拉琴不是用臂…卻是用手腕…